Skip to main content
All CollectionsPlumbing
Addressing Broken or Cracked Toilet Tank Lids, Bowls, or Seats
Addressing Broken or Cracked Toilet Tank Lids, Bowls, or Seats
N
Written by Nathan Toothman
Updated over 3 months ago

Broken or cracked components of a toilet, such as the tank lid, bowl, or seat, can compromise its functionality, appearance, and safety. Fixing or replacing these parts promptly prevents further damage, restores usability, and improves the aesthetics of the bathroom.

Common Causes of Cracks or Breakage

1. Accidental Impact:

• Dropping heavy objects on the toilet can crack or break ceramic components.

2. Wear and Tear:

• Over time, stress and repeated use can weaken the structure of toilet seats, lids, and bowls.

3. Improper Installation:

• Incorrect tightening of bolts or improper handling during installation can cause cracks.

4. Temperature Changes:

• Rapid changes in temperature may cause ceramic components to expand or contract, leading to cracks.

Fixing or Replacing Toilet Components

1. Broken or Cracked Tank Lid

Temporary Fix:

Materials Needed: Epoxy adhesive or super glue.

Steps:

1. Clean the lid and dry it thoroughly.

2. Apply adhesive to the cracked edges and press them together.

3. Hold in place until the adhesive sets, and allow it to cure fully.

Note: This is a temporary solution; a replacement is recommended for structural integrity.

Replacement:

• Purchase a replacement tank lid matching your toilet model or a universal lid.

• Place the new lid gently on the tank to avoid further damage.

2. Cracked or Broken Toilet Bowl

Inspection:

• Check if the crack is superficial or structural.

Superficial Cracks: Often seen on the surface and may not require immediate replacement.

Structural Cracks: Extend deeper and can lead to leaks, requiring immediate replacement.

Temporary Fix for Small Cracks:

Materials Needed: Waterproof epoxy or porcelain repair kit.

Steps:

1. Clean the cracked area and let it dry.

2. Apply epoxy to the crack and smooth it with a spatula or tool.

3. Allow it to cure for the time recommended by the product.

Warning: Do not use a temporarily repaired toilet if cracks appear near the base or water seals.

Replacement:

Steps:

1. Shut off the water supply and empty the tank and bowl.

2. Unscrew and remove the toilet from the floor flange.

3. Install a new toilet, ensuring the wax ring and flange are properly aligned.

4. Tighten bolts and reconnect the water supply.

3. Broken Toilet Seat

Fixing a Loose or Damaged Seat:

Tools Needed: Screwdriver, replacement bolts, or nuts.

Steps:

1. Tighten the seat bolts if loose.

2. Replace stripped or broken bolts with new ones.

Replacing a Broken Seat:

Steps:

1. Remove the old seat by unscrewing the bolts.

2. Clean the mounting area.

3. Align the new seat with the bolt holes and secure it in place.

Preventing Damage to Toilet Components

1. Avoid Impact:

• Keep heavy objects away from the toilet to reduce the risk of accidental drops.

2. Regular Maintenance:

• Inspect and tighten bolts periodically to prevent stress on components.

3. Use Quality Materials:

• Invest in durable seats, lids, and fittings to minimize wear and tear.

4. Protect Against Temperature Changes:

• Avoid exposing the toilet to extreme hot or cold conditions.

When to Call a Professional

• If the cracks extend into the base or internal structure of the toilet.

• For replacing a toilet bowl or entire unit.

• If there are leaks or structural damage beyond a DIY fix.

Cost of Repairs or Replacement

DIY Repairs:

• $5–$20 for epoxy, adhesive, or repair kits.

• $20–$50 for a new toilet seat or lid.

Replacement Costs:

• $150–$500+ for a new toilet, depending on the model and features.

Professional Repairs:

• $100–$300 for labor to replace components or install a new toilet.

Why Address Broken or Cracked Components Immediately?

1. Prevents Further Damage:

• Stops cracks from worsening and causing leaks.

2. Enhances Safety:

• Reduces the risk of injury from sharp edges or instability.

3. Restores Functionality:

• Ensures the toilet operates effectively and looks complete.

4. Improves Appearance:

• Maintains a clean and polished look in the bathroom.

Repairing or replacing broken toilet components is essential to maintaining a safe, functional, and aesthetically pleasing bathroom. While minor fixes are manageable with basic tools, professional help ensures durable and effective solutions for more significant issues.

Did this answer your question?